When you’re ready to commission a custom pet portrait, one of the first questions you’ll face is:
Should you choose a traditional oil painting or a modern digital portrait?
Both options can make a great keepsake or gift, but they offer very different experiences, aesthetics, and price points. Below, we break down the pros and cons of each so you can make the best choice for your home and your style.
Oil Pet Portraits: Timeless, Tangible, and One-of-a-Kind
Oil paintings have been cherished for centuries—and for good reason. They’re physical, textured, and truly one-of-a-kind works of art.
Pros of Oil Paintings
✔ A timeless, classic look
Oil portraits have a richness and depth that prints and screens can’t replicate. They glow as if from the inside due to layers of pigment.
✔ Textured, hand-painted detail
The brushstrokes add dimension and emotion. Each stroke is unique and created by hand, giving the portrait an authentic, artistic feel.
✔ Makes a strong statement
Oil paintings look especially stunning on walls. They can become the focal point of a room and blend well with fine art décor.
✔ Long-lasting
Oil portraits, when cared for properly, will last and won’t fade.
✔ No Glass
Oil portraits do not need to be protected by glass, unlike many prints.
Cons of Oil Paintings
✘ More expensive
Because they take longer to create and use higher-cost materials, oil portraits are usually the premium option.
✘ Longer turnaround time
Drying time alone can add days.
✘ Less flexible for revisions
Changes are possible but harder once the paint is down.
Digital Pet Portraits: Modern, Versatile, and Budget-Friendly
Digital portraits have become incredibly popular for their flexibility and affordability—without necessarily sacrificing artistry.
Pros of Digital Portraits
✔ Fast turnaround
Many digital artists offer quick delivery as it takes them less effort to make the product.
✔ Easily customizable
Want a certain background? Outfit? Color palette? Digital makes it simple.
✔ Budget-friendly
Because each piece is made using digital tools or AI, the artist spends less time on the product, so they tend to cost less.
✔ Unlimited print options
You can print your portrait on canvas, paper, mugs, apparel, or even create multiple copies.
✔ Great for gifts
Fast to produce, easy to deliver, and versatile in format.
Cons of Digital Portraits
✘ Lacks the physical texture of traditional paint
A digital portrait, even when printed on canvas, won’t have the true, dimensional brushstrokes or the layers of pigment as in an oil painting.
✘ Can feel less “fine art” depending on style
Some digital styles look more cartoon-like or graphic (which may or may not be what you want).
✘ Print and frame costs vary
While the portrait itself may be cheaper, high-quality printing and framing can add cost.
So… Which Is Better?
The real answer is: it depends on what you want from your artwork.
Choose an Oil Pet Portrait if:
-
You want a more traditional, luxurious, hand-painted, personalized look
-
You value original fine art
-
You want something high-quality
-
You prefer texture, depth, and the presence of real brushstrokes
Choose a Digital Pet Portrait if:
-
You’re looking for a modern or highly stylized artwork
-
You want something affordable
-
You want the flexibility of multiple prints
-
You need a fast turnaround
My Professional Recommendation as a Pet Portrait Artist
If a client wants something emotional, classic, and super quality, oil always wins. It has soul, texture, and the presence of traditional craftsmanship.
If a client wants something fast, flexible, or stylized, digital is the better match.
Both are beautiful mediums—it just depends on what you want hanging on your wall… or printed on your mug!
Final Thoughts
Your pet is family, and the artwork you choose should reflect your style, your space, and your budget. Whether you go with the timeless beauty of oil or the modern versatility of digital art, a custom pet portrait is one of the most meaningful ways to celebrate your pet.